Cookie Butter Pie – Cookies and Cups

/ Food 24 / By

Shelly

Cookie Butter Pie is an extremely simple and scrumptious pie recipe. A cookie crust stuffed with a whipped, creamy cookie butter mousse!

This recipe is in partnership with Imperial Sugar. Discover the FULL RECIPE on their web site.

Cookie Butter pie in a white pie plate topped with whipped cream, crushed cookies, and drizzled Biscoff spread

Cookie Butter Pie Is A Favourite Pie Recipe!

Cookie Butter, Biscoff, Speculoos unfold…no matter you name it everyone knows it’s scrumptious. A bit of like graham crackers and somewhat like gingersnaps, it’s a scrumptious cookie that additionally is available in a selection! I’ve added an entire lot of cookie butter into this creamy, simple pie, and also you’ll undoubtedly be going again for seconds!

This pie is a stunner. It’s assured to get you rave evaluations and requests for the recipe. I’m telling you it’s all the time the only desserts which are the most effective. And sure you completely may make this with peanut butter as an alternative of cookie butter!

Cookie Butter Pie on a plate with whipped cream

What You Will Want / Components

That is Cookie Butter Pie is a really easy to make with easy components. Be sure to jump over to Imperial Sugar for the complete checklist of components!

The Cookie Crust

  • Speculoos cookies. These are also referred to as Biscoff cookies (yep the sort you get on the airplane!) You’ll crush these cookies up for the crust of your pie. If you happen to can’t discover them you should use graham crackers for a graham cracker crust. Simply add a teaspoon of cinnamon to the combination!
  • Mild brown sugar. That is actually to sweeten the crust as a lot because it helps work to make the crust much less crumbly!
  • Kosher salt. Only a pinch to steadiness out the sweetness of the cookies!
  • Melted butter. I choose utilizing salted butter on this recipe, however unsalted works nice too.

The Cookie Butter Pie Filling

  • Cream cheese at room temperature. Preserving it mushy helps it combine easily with no lumps!
  • Powdered sugar
  • Vanilla extract
  • Cookie Butter aka Biscoff unfold. The Dealer Joe’s model known as Cookie Butter and it’s scrumptious, however Biscoff unfold is similar, so get no matter is handy it gained’t matter or impact the style in any respect!
  • Cool Whip. Sure you possibly can completely use selfmade whipped cream!

Directions / How To Make Cookie Butter Pie

Make the crust: In a meals processor or blender, crush the Biscoff cookies till they’re a wonderful crumb. Stir them along with the brown sugar, salt, and melted butter till evenly blended. 

Press the combination into the underside and up the perimeters of a 9- inch pie plate and bake the crust for 8 minutes, or till calmly golden in a 350°F oven. Enable the pie crust to chill utterly earlier than transferring on to creating the filling.

An unbaked cookie pie crust in a white pie dish

Make the filling: Within the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment combine the cream cheese, powdered sugar, vanilla, and cookie butter collectively on medium-high pace for two minutes till mild and fluffy. Fold within the Cool Whip till evenly included. 

Fluffy cream cheese mousse with swirls of cookie butter spread in a mixing bowl
a mixing bowl filled with Cookie Butter cheesecake mousse

Unfold the cookie butter combination into the cooled pie crust. Cowl and chill for 3 – 4 hours, or in a single day. 

Garnish with whipped cream, crushed cookies, and drizzled cookie butter if desired. Serve chilled. 

fluffy mousse in a cookie pie crust before being spread
Cookie Butter Pie in a pie dish whipped with whipped cream

How To Garnish Cookie Butter Pie

You may merely serve this pie as-is or make it fairly with garnishes. Listed below are some concepts:

  • Dollop on or pipe some whipped cream swirls across the edges. You can too use Cool Whip for this too! You could possibly even cowl all the prime of the pie with whipped cream!
  • Crush up some further cookies and sprinkle the cookie crumbs on prime!
  • Break the cookies into greater items and press them into the sides!
  • Warmth up some further Biscoff or Cookies Butter unfold within the microwave and drizzle it on prime. It’s simpler to drizzle when it’s heat!
Cookie Butter Pie with a slice cut in a pie plate from above

Can You Make This Pie In Advance?

This pie can completely be made forward for a celebration or gathering. In reality, it wants some chill time, so make it the evening earlier than and also you’ll have dessert able to go. That is particularly useful across the holidays when your kitchen is further busy!

A biscoff mousse pie in a white pie plate with a slice cut

How To Retailer

This pie must be saved chilled so cowl it with cling wrap and retailer hermetic within the fridge for as much as 5 days. You can too freeze it for as much as 30 days for greatest freshness. Thaw it within the fridge in a single day, and even take pleasure in it frozen!

Discover the complete recipe HERE!

Love Pie? Right here Are A number of Recipes You May Love

PIN for later:

Cookie Butter Pie Image Collage for Pinterest

#Cookie #Butter #Pie #Cookies #Cups

Scroll to Top